Carruthers begins in London, tired of an empty late-season routine. A letter from his old acquaintance Davies invites him to sail in the Baltic. Davies has brought the Dulcibella to the Frisian coast in the northwest of Germany. The invitation grants Carruthers's wish for an escape, but the boat is small and uncomfortable, far from the holiday vessel he imagined. By joining it, he also enters Davies's unfinished problem.
Davies studies the shallow Frisian waters with unusual care. A line on a broad chart may cross open blue space, yet a real channel must be deep enough for the yacht at that hour of the tide. Soundings give depth one point at a time. Between them, Davies must judge banks, currents and the vessel's draught.
Direction alone cannot settle the route. The channel lies to the east. The chart may require an eastward approach before a northward turn enters it. Current and wind can then carry the boat away from the intended track. Davies repeatedly compares compass, tide, sounding and landmarks, correcting one clue against the others.
Near the seaside, calm sea can give Carruthers a false sense of open water. At low tide, broad banks emerge where a visitor had seen only a shining surface. At high tide, those banks disappear without making every line safe. The changing water explains why a charted route must be read with time as well as position.
Davies is also reading human behaviour. He believes another sailor guided him toward a dangerous shoal, then tried to hide his purpose behind an easy explanation. The event might have been an accident. To convince Carruthers otherwise, Davies has to connect the sailor's movements with courses, tides and the positions of boats. Carruthers begins to seek a pattern, using navigation details as evidence about intention.
Back aboard the Dulcibella, Carruthers is far from the comfortable holiday he expected. Every correction to the route now sits beside a question about intention. The same habit guides both inquiries: a single mark, movement or story remains provisional until it agrees with other evidence. Carruthers must now learn the coast and learn when another person's explanation deserves doubt.